Guides

Is your soccer card a true rookie or yet another fake?

One of a few Pele Rookies from 1958, from Aquarela collection #10

I admit it. If a couple of years ago you asked me what a rookie card (RC) is, you would have caught me off-guard. As a profound trading card collector, I felt a bit ashamed not to know the meaning of this widely-used term in collecting circles..

When I wanted to find out what on earth a “rookie card” is, the variety of opinions and definitions left me completely clueless.

Gosh, its impossible to please everyone!

After  lots of discussions with experienced collectors specialized in this aspect of the hobby, I realized there are 2 main debates over the rookie card definition.

#1 Sportsman first appearance card regardless of brand

Vast majority of collectors claim that a rookie card is the card on which player appeared the  first time in his career, regardless of the brand. According to this broadly accepted definition, the first released card featuring sports star is his rookie card, regardless of the collection, brand or the country of origin.

#2 First appearance printed by the major publisher

This concept was introduced by the Beckett, a US company specialized in trading card grading and price guides. According to them a rookie card is “first licensed issue from a major manufacturer that is widely distributed“.There are pros and cons of this definition.

By relaying on major brands as a rookie resource, the possibility of fake cards and DIY cards is nearly eliminated. This means that if little Tommy down the street who is a computer geek, decided to print his own card of Leo Messi from 2003 and sell it on eBay, since the card is not from a certified, official collection, it will not be accepted as a rookie.

According to this definition a rookie card is considered to be only the one that’s been issued by the publishers such as Panini, Topps or Upper Deck and couple of others.

In addition to the brand importance, there is one more thing. “Widely distributed” part of the definition is a bit hard to understand. Since Beckett is focused on the US market, they probably mean that card has to be distributed in the US in order for them to accept it as a rookie.

This is the problematic part. Why on earth should only widely distributed cards be rookies? Yes it eliminates the possibility of frauds, but it also limits the whole hobby.

This definition can be applied to the baseball, American football and hockey cards perhaps, but as far as soccer cards are concerned this view is not acceptable because 95% of all soccer collections comes outside the USA.

How to know if the card you have or want is a rookie?

Lets now be realistic. Buying online is great way to find bargains and hidden treasures. You as a collector probably enjoy browsing through online card stores sites, eBay or Amazon which are best places to buy rookies.

The other side of the coin is cruel.

Lots of the sellers are after your money.

They do not chose the means to get the money out of your wallet. Sellers will often list a card as a “rookie” even if it is not.

Why? 

Well duh, they want your money!

Some of them do not have the knowledge, so they list each and every card as a rookie, because – it appears that putting “rookie” in description brings more profit. Others on the other hand do have a knowledge, but they use all sorts of dirty tricks to earn a buck or two.

Check out the photo bellow. There are tons of Luis Suarez rookie soccer cards according to these sellers.

So how on earth can a honest collector like yourself fight against these jerks?

Illustration of fake Luis Suarez rookie soccer card
Illustration of fake Luis Suarez rookie cards. Photo from eBay.com

Unfortunately when it comes to soccer cards there is no database or a website that can show you what card is a true rookie.

So you are bombarded with millions of rookies of your favorite player, there is no database or a reliable resource to help you out, when you go to the forums, everyone will say something different.

Who do you trust?

Yourself.

You my friend are the only one in this whole wide world who won’t trick you.

This means that you have to do a research before you buy a rookie card of your favorite football/soccer or any other player. You do not buy based on what other say because its just too risky.

Step by step guide in finding if the card is a true rookie

When I wanted to created a list of best rookie cards a year ago I was furious with the amount of crap people put online.

There are so many inaccurate guides and ways to find weather the soccer card you are after is a true rookie.

Here are the steps I take when researching each and every rookie card I am after. You shouldn’t skip these steps.

1) Players biography research

Decide what player you want to research. As an example I‘ll use notorious Luis Suarez.

Enter players name in Google search and go to his biography (use reliable sites as a resource, such as Wikipedia)

Find a list of all the teams your player played in. As for Luis Suarez example, according the the Wikipedia :

“In May 2005, at age 18, he made his first team debut…”

Oh yea! Got it. 2005/6 is the first season notorious Luis Suarez played his first official match – his rookie season.

2) Team/league research

After you discovered a team where player played when he started, you have to see in which league team played.

Example : So besides discovering that he headbutted a referee at the age of 16, I found out that Luis Suarez played for the Uruguayan – National. Since I have modest knowledge on football league in Uruguay, I found out that National played in the first league in 2005, and finished second.

Now I know that potential rookie Suarez card/sticker is collection about First Uruguayan league 2005/6.

3) Finding a collection

The next step is the hardest.It can make or break your effort.

You have to use internet to explore and find out if a collection for that particular season exists. If it does, is the team your player played at is included? And if the team is included , is your player in that collection, or was he left out since he was just another young gun?

Example : I started by typing keywords in the Google.

  • “2005-2006 Uruguay album”
  • figurinhas, cromos futebol Uruguayo 2005/6 (I used figurinhas and cromos which are words for stickers/cards in Portuguese and Spanish).
  • Futebol Uruguayo 2005 album was my third luck.

I found out  that there is a collection about the Uruguayan First football league for 2005/6 season. Gotcha!

This is a potential collection that might include a rookie player I am after (or may not).

Untitled-1

4) Finding if a player is in collection

You found a collection. Now you have to find out if your player is in it. The best way to discover if a player is included in the collection is to find a checklist.

For popular sets, it will be easy to find this sort of information. Simple Google search should do the job. However, some of the collections with a rookie card were made locally, usually by a small publishing company. It happens that a checklist does not exist, or its hard to find it.

What you can do is to join the local collectors forums and ask a question. If the item you found is for sale, contact the seller. Alternatively if you already have a couple of reliable collectors in your list, email them and ask, perhaps someone knows.

Here is a template I use for the sellers on eBay. Remember, your message must be polite, and you should act as being really interested in the collection.

Hello,

I just saw your item “Collection Name” and I am interested in buying it.

Before I buy it, I would like to know if “Team name” is included in this collection? If it is, can you please tell me if “Your player name” is in it?

Thanks in advance.

Sincerely.

“Your name”

Example : After being unable to find a checklist for “Futebol Uruguyo Campeonato Apertura 2005” mini stickers album by Panini, I had to contact an eBay sellers who had it, and ask for the info. At the same time I got in touch with a fellow collector Alan, who is a master at checklists.

info via seller rookie cards

5) If you fail, try again

When you are 100% sure that the player you are looking for does not appear on the card in his rookie season, move onto the next season. Move to the next season when you are 100% sure that your player hasn’t been featured in a collection.

As you can see, doing a research on a rookie card can be a pain it the ass for some. But if you are a true hobby enthusiast, willing to discover hidden gems made around the world, this process should be fun and educational. I personally enjoy doing a research. It helped me with finding out some of the most insane rookie soccer cards and get in touch with collectors around the globe.

To conclude, it may sound as a Sprite commercial, but you should follow your own instinct. Enjoy the research. Connect with other people interested in this type of cards. Make contacts. Have a database and feel free to share it with the others. You never know what treasure you may find next.

Example : At the moment of publishing this post, I was still unable to get a reply from the sellers. I will continue my research and let you know if I was able to confirm that a true rookie soccer card of Luis Suarez is from Uruguayan Panini Futebol 2005 Mini album. If its not, I will move on to the next collection.

Which are the most valuable RC rookie soccer cards in 2014?

Bellow is an overview of top 3 most expensive rookie cards on the market currently. Please note that I included the average price of the card during the 90 day period.

Lionel Leo Messi – Panini MegaCracks 2004-05 BIS #71

Leo Messi Rookie soccer card #71 MegaCracks 2004-5
Messi Rookie Card MegaCracks 2004/05 #71 Bis (ungraded and professionally graded card on the right) photography mysoccercards.com

Leo Messi is one of the greatest soccer players of all time. His first season in FC Barcelona was in 2004. Spain is probably the most developed European country when it comes to number of collections issued about their national league.

That is why there are three cards considered to be Messi’s  rookies. The most valuable one is certainly a card from Mega Cracks 2004/2005 collection where Leo appeared as an update card (BIS) #71. This particular rookie card sells for an average of 510,80$. Highest price in the 2014 was 4999$ for two graded Messi rookies, where as the lowest price was little above 120$.

In period from 1.7.2014-28.92014 31 sold Messi #71 BIS MegaCracks 2004/2005 card generated a total sales of $15,835 on eBay with 33,33% sell-through rate, which means that every third card listed gets sold.

Pele rookie soccer card – Aquarela #10

Edson Arantes do Nascimento – Pele is officially the best football player ever. There are couple of his rookie cards, and it is really hard to determine which one is the first. When it comes to the value, the most sought after would be Pele Aquarela #10. The average that this card sells for is 432$. The all other Pele rookie cards sell for an average of 290$.

One of a few Pele Rookies from 1958, from Aquarela collection #10
One of a few Pele Rookies from 1958, from Aquarela collection #10 photo by mysoccercards.com

Cristiano Ronaldo – Panini MegaCracks 2002/3 #137

Cristiano Ronaldo first got featured in a card collection when he played for Portuguese Sporting. There are his rookie card and sticker from the 2002/3 season. Obviously, the more expensive one is his #137 “Jovens Promessas”  (young prospect) card from Portuguese Mega Cracks 2002-2003.

Ronaldo’s rookie sells for an average of 150-200$ on eBay. Since too many sellers listed cards that are not his rookie, I am unable to give more precise valuation.

Rookie card of young Cristiano Ronaldo from MegaCracks 2002/3 #137 while he was in Sporting
Rookie card of young Cristiano Ronaldo from MegaCracks 2002/3 #137 while he was in Sporting Photography mysoccercards.com

Who do you collect?

If you are a rookie card collector, who is your favorite player? What is your way of finding if a card is a true rookie? Let me know in the comments bellow and feel free to ask any question that you might have.

Collecting this one? Trade cards and stickers and talk about it on the forum.

15 comments.

  1. If i would buy a rookie card it would be Pirlo or Buffon two of my favorite players of Italia

  2. What a wonderful article, Pavle! I had some thoughts on how to know which stickers and cards are rookies, but you enhanced it a lot! I was already thinking why you took that long to write another article, but now I understand why, it’s probably one of your best articles so far :)

    About this rookie question… Ok, can I be honest? I’m beginning to despise some “rookie seekers”! I don’t mean those buyers who show up and pay their value, I’m referring to people who just want to get rookie stickers for cents/pennies and are always searching for dumb, ignorant people… Constantly asking for info, giving some lame excuses, even deceive others… I’m through with them and now, NOBODY will get that info from me.

    Being from Portugal and after some years “in the business”, I know how Ronaldo rookie card and sticker are worth… And it freakin’ annoys me how in the last couple of years, many sellers realized how these items are sought and so, they began also a quest to find every single Ronaldo rookie card/sticker they could get… I know some three or four portuguese sellers that are constantly harassing others on many websites just to check if someone have them… And actually, they’re some of the worst “collectors” (note the “”) I’ve ever dealt with… Lousy quality items, poor communication and greedy as hell.

    I could rant even more about this issue (and giving some fresh examples about this annoying quest), but it would take me hours hehe.

    1. Thanks a lot Carlos :) I admit, it took me a bit longer then usual. I was hoping that the sellers from eBay might reply about my Suarez question. I also have to add more info on “best selling rookies” part.
      I totally understand why you do not like when people are trying to trick others so that they can make quick buck.
      Obviously Portuguese and Spanish modern day collections do have a nice amount of rookies :)

  3. nice article! cool
    i have heard Luis suarez rc is when i play in fc groening in dutch league
    the ronaldo(brasil ) rookie card with feeynoord is expensive too…

    1. Thanks Klarc! I am still researching for the 2005 season about Suarez, but you are right, it appears his rookie is from FC Groningen in the 2006/7. Will update the article when I find out more.

        1. Also, do you know if I can find any checklists for Panini Megacracks 2004-05 online?
          Cheers

  4. This is great information! When it comes to USA market sports like Baseball,basketball, & American football have the symbol Rookie already placed on the card.

    If I want to find a rookie baseball card it’s not that difficult since it already says it on the card.

    1. Thanks Illias!
      There is a monopoly in the USA market where only 2-3 big brands issue cards I believe. In other parts of the world there are still small publishers trying to find their way to market their products.

      1. Yea I can understand about US companies. I feel like they flood the collecting market. Which is good and bad

  5. Hi,Pavle,

    It’s an interesting topic,actually,the definition of rookie is still arguable.Some people like real card,others like myself also accept the sticker.The interesting fact is that some players doesn’t exist
    individual card/sticker on HIS early career,but they would be suprisingly involved in squad card/sticker in local/foreign issue,which most of common trading company would ignore.For instance,as far as I am concerned,the real rookie card of Ronaldo(Brazilian striker)is from 1994 local collection,instead of that widely-circulated PSV card/sticker.Also,I doubt many people know that the real rookie card of van Persie is from Japanese NTV Urawa promo card,which included RVP from the Feyenoord squad of 2001- 2002 UEFA Cup FINAL starting XI.

    1. Hi Li,

      Thanks :) I totally agree with you on that one. I personally do not make a difference between a card and a sticker when it comes to rookies. However plenty of other collectors do. Its the matter of personal preference.
      Great info you shared here about RVP rookie, very interesting. Oh, I thought that Ronaldo Rookie is from 1995, amazing discovery! Do you have any photos of these? Feel free to share some on our forums if you wish.

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Collecting this one? Swap and talk about it with other collectors on the forum.